• Home
  • Business
  • Finance
  • Food
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Environment
  • Travel
  • Events
  • Classifieds
  • More
    • Editor’s Note
    • Book Reviews
    • Education
    • Health & Home
    • History
    • Art & Music
    • Point of View
    • Rubrique Francaise
    • Science
    • Technology
    • The Bridge
    • Videos

Advertisement
TAN Book

Climate Change: It’s Not The Science, It’s The Policy

on November 5th, 2014 by The Afro News 0 comments

Advertisement
TheAfroNewsBook

The Real Issue Is Less The “Disease” Than It is The Proposed Treatment For Climate Change

The United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has released its latest “Synthesis Report” drawing together the findings of the most recent three-volume set of the Fifth Assessment Report. The Assessment Report is meant to be the last word – at least until the next omnibus review is done – on climate change science and policy options.

Let’s set the science stuff aside for the moment (I’m a climate-accepter, though on the modest end of the worry-range), because the real issue is less the “disease” than it is the proposed treatment for climate change.
Based on the findings of the synthesis report, the UN is calling for almost a complete end to fossil fuel use by 2100, with the majority of that decarbonization to take place before 2050.

Carbon-based fuels are, by far, the least-cost fuels for reliable electricity production, and for powering the world’s transportation system. Raising power costs by switching to nuclear, wind, solar, and biofuels would seriously degrade our quality of life, pricing development out of the reach of more than two billion people around the world. For Canada, that prescription would be particularly damaging, as it calls for an end to oil sands production, and abandonment of Canada’s coal, oil and natural gas resources. That’s a major chunk of Canada’s economy eliminated by 2050.

Environmentalists and green-energy hucksters promise to power the world with wind and sunlight, but that’s highly unlikely – wind and solar power are expensive and unreliable forms of energy generation with their own significant environmental impacts. The most authoritative source that compares the costs of different kinds of electricity generation on an apples-to-apples basis (energy economists call this the “levelized cost of power”) is the U.S. Energy Information Administration. In its most recent estimations, the EIA lists the cost of generating new coal power (looking to 2019 construction) at $96/MWh; natural gas at about $65/MWh; solar power comes in between $130/MWh and $243/MWh depending on how you generate it. Wind looks slightly better than it has in the past, at an estimated $80/MWh for on-shore wind, but wind carries problems that transcend price – it’s intermittent, it requires redundant back-up power sources, and it comes with its own set of environmental headaches.

And let’s look at Canada’s own experience with green energy. Last year, in a study for the Fraser Institute, Ross McKitrick (Fraser Institute Senior Fellow and economics professor at the University of Guelph) looked at the mess that Ontario got itself into following the green energy playbook. What McKitrick found was that, in pursuit of a renewable-energy transition in Ontario, power prices were driven to some of the highest rates in North America, with additional rate hikes of 40 to 50 per cent pending in the next few years. His study showed that 80 per cent of the wind-power generated in Ontario was out of phase with demand, and that this surplus power was sold to the United States at a loss to Ontarians. McKitrick found that Ontario already lost more than $2 billion on wind power, with additional losses of $200 million/year ongoing.

Adding insult to injury, the very modest environmental benefits realized by Ontario through the transition to renewables could have been secured at one-tenth the cost if the province had simply continued to use existing technologies to retrofit existing coal plants.

Advocates for greenhouse gas controls are waving the UN’s newest synthesis report around, asserting that arguments over climate policy are now over, as the UN’s definitive climate diagnosis has produced a prescription that cannot be questioned. Disagree with them on any particular, from the potential scale of the threat to the impacts of their proposed policies – even if you use the UN’s own data to support your position – and they’ll label you a “denier.” But here’s what can’t be denied: the policy prescriptions of the ENGOs and the United Nations would hike energy prices worldwide, perpetuating energy poverty for billions of people, and debilitating the few bright economic engines left in the world. It’s a prescription far worse than the disease.

By Kenneth P. Green

Kenneth P. Green is Senior Director, Natural Resource Studies at The Fraser Institute. Follow him on Twitter: @KennethPGreen.
www.troymedia.com

Filed under: Environment, Environment Tagged With: biofuels, Climate Change, Disease, Environmentalists, Green Energy

21st Red Carpet Gala Awards Celebration of Leo Awards 2019

[SLGF id=18667]

Related Posts

  • The Toxic Truth Behind “Green Energy” Technologies, Cobalt, and the Exploitation of the Congo 
  • Net Zero Has Been A Boon to Dictators
  • Climate Change Places Older Adults at Greater Risk
  • Suing Oil Companies Over Climate Change will Only Hurt Taxpayers
  • Climate Change Is A Global Health Emergency

Next post: Rationing Healthcare Done Differently In Canada And The US

Previous post: 7 Ways to Cut Your Holiday Expenses

Follow TAN

  • youtube
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • linkedin

Grow Your Business With TAN

Grow Your Business With TAN

Advertise On Our New Classifieds Section

List Your Classified Ad Now

Stay Informed
Sign Up To Get Your Weekly Roundup of the News
We promise not to spam you. Unsubscribe at any time.
Invalid email address
Thanks for subscribing!Be sure to look for your confirmation email and confirm your subscription.

Write a Letter to the Editor

Send A Letter To Our Editor Now!

Classifieds

Visit Our Classifieds Section

Advertisement

Advertisements

> Navigate Our Site

  • Book Reviews
  • Business
  • Editor’s Note
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Environment
  • Events
  • Finance
  • Food
  • Health & Home
  • History
  • Art & Music
  • Point of View
  • Rubrique Francaise
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Technology
  • The Bridge
  • Travel
  • Videos

> Extra Resources

  • Advertising
  • Post a Classified Ad
  • TAN History
  • Letter to the Editor
  • SAGE Foundation
  • TAN Facebook
  • TAN Twitter
  • La Palabre Podcast
  • Writers Login
  • youtube
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • linkedin
Back To Top

Copyright © ’2023’ The Afro News, a PGH company
All Rights Reserved